Is Pilates the New Yoga? What Pregnant & Postnatal Women Need to Know

My husband said something recently that made me laugh: “Cortisol is the new carb, and fibre is the new protein.”

He’s right. Every few years, there’s a new health trend that dominates our feeds. And right now, it feels like Pilates is having its moment.

Pilates studios are everywhere. Reformer classes are booked solid. My Instagram feed is full of strong, empowered women doing Pilates.

And I get it. I go to mat Pilates once a week, and I love it. My body feels amazing after: aligned, strong, connected.

But as a prenatal and postnatal yoga teacher, I’ve been asking myself: Is Pilates the new yoga? And if so, what does that mean for women navigating pregnancy, birth, and motherhood?

Why Pilates Is Having a Moment

Here’s my theory: Pilates gives you physical and mental benefits without asking you to go deeper.

You don’t have to chant. You don’t have to meditate. You don’t have to explore your chakras or connect to something spiritual.

You show up. You move your body. You feel good. Done.

In a world where we’re already overwhelmed and overstimulated, maybe that simplicity is exactly what people are craving.

But I also wonder: Is Pilates just the new fad? Because let’s be honest, yoga was a fad 20 years ago. And in many ways, it still is.

Where Yoga and Pilates Actually Overlap

Before we talk about differences, let’s acknowledge the similarities. Because there are many.

Pilates classes often incorporate yoga poses. They just give them different names.

As a yoga teacher, I’ll admit this makes me a little mad. When an instructor says “inverted V” instead of Downward-Facing Dog, or ends class with palms together at the heart (that’s Anjali Mudra, a yoga mudra), or even finishes in Savasana, these are all yoga practices.

And I understand why Pilates borrows from yoga. These poses work. They’ve worked for thousands of years.

In fact, in postnatal yoga, we use many of the same movements you’d see in Pilates because they’re effective for core strength, pelvic stability, and postpartum recovery.

So the physical overlap is huge.

The difference isn’t really about the poses. It’s about what else yoga brings to the table.

What Makes Yoga Different

Pilates is a physical conditioning system focused on core strength, alignment, control, and breath coordination. It’s methodical, effective, and it makes you strong.

Yoga does all of that too: the strength, the flexibility, the alignment, the breath work.

But yoga also includes breathwork for nervous system regulation (pranayama), meditation, philosophy (the yamas and niyamas), and energy work like mudras and mantras.

In other words, yoga includes everything Pilates does, plus another dimension.

Why Yoga’s Depth Matters During Motherhood

Pregnancy and postpartum aren’t just physical changes. They’re identity shifts.

Your body is transforming. Your hormones are unpredictable. Your nervous system is on high alert. You’re grieving who you were while trying to figure out who you’re becoming.

This isn’t just about building core strength. This is about navigating one of the most profound transitions of your life.

And this is where yoga’s “extra dimension” becomes essential.

Breathwork for Regulation

In Pilates, breath is functional. In yoga, breath is a tool for nervous system regulation.

I used breathwork during my twin labour with no pain relief, just breath. It worked because I had practiced it not as a fitness technique, but as a way to regulate my body’s response to intensity.

Philosophy for Mindset

Yoga’s ethical guidelines like ahimsa (non-violence) and satya (truthfulness) aren’t just ancient concepts. They’re survival tools.

When you’re terrified of birth, ahimsa asks: How can I stop fighting my body and start trusting it?

When you’re comparing yourself to other mothers postpartum, satya asks: What’s actually true here?

Sitting in Silence Together

Both Pilates and yoga create community in group classes. But yoga offers something unique: sitting in silence together, breathing together, chanting Om together.

When you’re in a prenatal yoga class, eyes closed, breathing with other pregnant women, you’re not just exercising. You’re sharing the experience of being in your body during this massive transition.

That collective stillness creates a different kind of connection.

Maybe Simple and Boring Works Best

Let’s be honest: Pilates (especially Reformer Pilates) looks cooler than yoga right now. The machines. The equipment. The aesthetic.

Compared to that, yoga might seem boring. You’re on a mat. Sometimes you’re just sitting. Breathing.

It’s not flashy.

But here’s what I’ve learned: The simple, boring things work best.

Consistent breathwork. Regular meditation. Showing up to the same class every week.

During pregnancy and postpartum, when everything feels chaotic, maybe what you need isn’t something flashy. Maybe you need something simple. Sustainable. Something that meets you where you are.

So Which One Should You Do?

Here’s where I land: If you just want to move your body and feel strong, do Pilates. It’s great.

But if you’re navigating pregnancy, birth, or the identity shift of motherhood, yoga offers something Pilates can’t.

And here’s the thing: You can do both. I do both.

I love my weekly Pilates class for strength and alignment. But I practice yoga because it supports my whole life, not just my body.

What do you think? Do you practice Pilates, yoga, or both? I’d love to hear your experience. Send me a message on Instagram @krish_yoga or email hello@krishyoga.com.

Ready to find out what hypnobirthing can actually do for you?

Join the next Cam & Confident Mama Course